Steelers Fans Finally Learn The Truth About What Really Went Down With George Pickens

The Pittsburgh Steelers made the big-time decision to trade star wide receiver George Pickens to the Dallas Cowboys ahead of the 2025 season. Pickens had developed into one of the league’s most physically gifted wideouts, but his time in Pittsburgh was consistently filled with controversy. 

Omar Khan, the Steelers' general manager, said the organization felt a fresh start was best for both sides, putting an end to the Pickens era with a short, but telling statement. The move, while surprising to some fans, was less about on-field production and more about maintaining a stable locker room culture. Mike Tomlin has always placed a premium on team-first players, and the front office is clearly focused on building a roster that reflects that mindset.

Since Pickens' departure, more stories have started to surface about what really happened behind closed doors. Steelers insider Gerry Dulac appeared on 102.5 WDVE’s Morning Show with Randy Baumann and offered more insight into why the team chose to part ways with the wide receiver. 

"It was so bad that they made the move right now and didn't even wait till later," Dulac said. "The litany of violations apparently were endless. I remember one of the players telling me last year during the season that the people internally don't even realize half the violations that he commits."

According to Dulac, the coaching staff had grown increasingly frustrated with Pickens' behavior and attitude, calling it a constant source of tension. 

While no one questions his talent, it became clear that the Steelers believed the headaches off the field were no longer worth the production on it.

"The players, they see that, they're not going to tolerate that. If the coaches and management don't do something about it, then they lose respect for them," Dulac said. "Mike Tomlin makes all roster decisions and the only way he doesn't is if Art Rooney [II] trumps him and says no, that's not going to happen. But Mike Tomlin had had enough. It just goes to show you how big a problem it had become that they thought they don't even wanna start the season with the guy."

From sideline outbursts to cryptic social media posts, Pickens often found himself at the center of drama, and eventually, Tomlin and the front office had seen enough. The team also faced the financial reality of an expiring rookie contract and likely wasn’t planning to offer a big extension. By trading him now, the Steelers secured valuable draft capital rather than risk losing him for nothing.

It's a tough reality for Steelers fans to watch yet another talented wide receiver forced out of the Steel City. Ahead of the 2024 season, Pittsburgh made a similar move by trading Diontae Johnson to the Carolina Panthers, parting ways with a player who was once seen as a top target in the league. Since then, Johnson has bounced around, briefly landing with the Baltimore Ravens and Houston Texans before ending up with the Cleveland Browns for the 2025 season.

Steelers' Mike Tomlin Appears To Know When To Move On From Wide Receivers

So far, Johnson's career has clearly taken a downward turn since leaving Pittsburgh. Historically, when Tomlin decides to move on from a wide receiver, he tends to be right. Still, the story isn’t finished yet, and many Steelers fans believe Pickens has the talent to break the trend. His ceiling remains incredibly high, even if his time in Pittsburgh was marked by inconsistency and distractions.

Pickens arrived in Pittsburgh with star potential but never fully lived up to it. While he flashed brilliance, his impact was overshadowed by constant drama and questions about maturity. Now, he'll get a fresh start in Dallas on a one-year prove-it deal, hoping to turn the page and finally become the dominant receiver many expected him to be.

#SteelerNation