The Pittsburgh Steelers have some big decisions to make in the 2025 offseason. The first huge decisions will come around the quarterback spot. The Steelers have been stuck in limbo at quarterback since Ben Roethlisberger retired. In 2024, Pittsburgh rocked with Justin Fields and Russell Wilson.
Taylor Ollason / Pittsburgh Steelers
Steelers' quarterbacks Justin Fields and Russell Wilson during OTAs.
Both quarterbacks showed highs and some lows, but their futures are uncertain in Pittsburgh. The Steelers were lucky to get both quarterbacks for very cost-friendly deals in 2024, but if they want to move forward with one or even both, it’s going to cost them a lot more. Steelers insider Gerry Dulac shared an interesting thought during his Steelers chat on Wednesday, hinting that Wilson may not be returning to Pittsburgh after all for the 2025 season.
Dulac’s comments have fueled speculation about the Steelers’ long-term plans under center. While Wilson brought veteran leadership and flashes of brilliance, his inconsistent performances have left fans divided on whether he’s the right fit moving forward. Fields, on the other hand, showcased his potential to grow into the role but has yet to prove himself fully. With both quarterbacks entering contract discussions, the Steelers are now faced with the challenge of choosing a path that aligns with their vision for the future.
"I'm not sure they're considering that," Dulac said in response to a question about bringing back Wilson.
This decision becomes even more complicated considering the cost implications. Wilson, though aging, could demand a significant financial commitment, while Fields’ potential upside makes him an appealing but risky option. The Steelers must weigh whether investing in one of their current quarterbacks is worth it or if exploring other options through free agency or the draft is the better route. Whatever they decide, the choice will define Pittsburgh’s trajectory for years to come, and fans are eager to see how it all unfolds.
Alysa Rubin / Pittsburgh Steelers
Steelers' Russell Wilson stands next to Head Coach Mike Tomlin during a game.
The case for Wilson is an intriguing one. Mike Tomlin has made it clear he holds Wilson in high regard, but the quarterback's inability to end his playoff drought will weigh heavily in contract discussions. Wilson has expressed a strong desire to return to Pittsburgh and seems genuinely happy in the Steel City. If he truly wants to stay, the 36-year-old could opt for a team-friendly deal, giving the Steelers the financial flexibility to address their other roster weaknesses.
Fields, meanwhile, benefited from extra opportunities in 2024 due to Wilson’s injuries. He made the most of those chances, showing steady improvement within the offense. However, reports surfaced suggesting Fields was being restricted, including not being allowed to call audibles, which raises questions about whether fans saw his full potential. His 4-2 record as a starter showcased promise, but it’s challenging to fully evaluate his performance under those circumstances.
The Steelers face several pivotal decisions this offseason, and the future of their quarterback position is at the forefront. Fans are both excited and anxious to see whether Wilson or Fields will earn a new contract to stay in Pittsburgh for 2025. Dulac, who is well-connected within the organization, has suggested that the team may not be particularly inclined to move forward with Wilson at this point in the offseason.
Steelers' Russell Wilson Might Have Played Himself Out Of Pittsburgh
Wilson went 6-5 after taking over the starting role following his calf injury. Early on, he showcased the ability to open up the offense, connecting on deep passes to George Pickens, Mike Williams, and Calvin Austin III. However, the Steelers' five-game losing streak late in the season has likely hurt his chances of securing a lucrative contract for 2025. While it doesn't completely rule him out, it does raise doubts about the team's long-term plans for him.
Charles LeClaire / Imagn Images
Steelers' Russell Wilson celebrates with wide receiver George Pickens during a 2024 regular season game.
Dulac believes the Steelers' interest in Wilson has waned, especially with Fields presenting a younger, potentially more dynamic option. However, questions still linger about whether Fields is the answer at quarterback. Some believe the Steelers might consider drafting a quarterback in the later rounds of the 2025 NFL Draft, though that comes with its own risks, given the current lack of a strong quarterback class. As the offseason unfolds, many of these questions will start to be answered.
#SteelerNation
