The Pittsburgh Steelers entered their Week 4 matchup against the Indianapolis Colts dealing with a few injuries. While the defense had been solid, one of their top performers, Alex Highsmith, was sidelined after suffering a groin injury in Week 3, which is expected to keep him out for at least two weeks. Although concerned, many Steelers fans remained hopeful, confident that Nick Herbig could step up in Highsmith's absence.

Steelers.com
Steelers' Alex Highsmith and Nick Herbig stand on the sideline during the National Anthem.
However, early in the game against the Colts, things took a turn for the worse. The defense was already struggling, and then it was announced that Herbig had been ruled out for the rest of the game due to an ankle injury, adding even more adversity to an already challenging situation.
Nick Herbig is OUT with an ankle
— 93.7 The Fan (@937theFan) September 29, 2024
Herbig, a fourth-round pick, made a strong impression during limited opportunities in his rookie season in 2023, generating plenty of excitement about his potential impact on the Steelers' defense. Many fans weren’t overly concerned about Highsmith’s injury, confident that Herbig could fill the void effectively.
Steelers' Defense Dealing With Two Major Injuries
While Highsmith’s injury was a setback—he’s a crucial part of the defense—there was optimism that Herbig could step up. Unfortunately, with Herbig now ruled out after suffering an ankle injury, the pressure falls on DeMarvin Leal to step into the role.

Karl Roser / Pittsburgh Steelers
Steelers' DeMarvin Leal ahead of Pittsburgh's victory over the Charges in 2024.
Steelers fans are now anxiously hoping Herbig’s injury isn’t severe and that he can return to action as soon as possible, though he's confirmed to miss the remainder of the Week 4 game against the Colts.
Great news has emerged for the Steelers. According to Rich Walsh, an error was made over the PA system during the game, which initially announced that Herbig had been ruled out. In reality, the Steelers had him listed as questionable. The even better news: Herbig is back on the field.
The press box PA mistakenly announced Herbig out… the Steelers had him questionable… anyway he’s back in @kdka. Sorry for confusion https://t.co/jO7ja1dwHz
— Rich Walsh KDKA (@RichieWalsh) September 29, 2024
With the Steelers struggling defensively in the first half, Herbig’s return is a huge boost as they look to turn things around. His presence will be crucial if they hope to secure a win. It's a relief for Steelers fans to see him back in action, especially after the earlier confusion.
#SteelerNation