The Steelers Could Get An Interesting Package If TJ Watt Gets Traded

The Pittsburgh Steelers have already had a noteworthy offseason, marked by both significant roster changes and lingering questions regarding the franchise's future direction. While the team has welcomed notable additions, such as veteran wide receiver DK Metcalf, whose acquisition involved a substantial five-year, $150 million contract, they have also experienced departures. Furthermore, the potential arrival of veteran quarterback Aaron Rodgers has dominated offseason discussions, fueling widespread speculation about him filling the Steelers' vacant starting quarterback role. Amidst the excitement surrounding these high-profile acquisitions, less attention has been directed toward current players who are either eligible for contract extensions or potentially facing the end of their tenure with the team. Among those currently engaged in contract negotiations is TJ Watt, one of the esteemed captains and a strong force within the Steelers' defense.

The perceived lack of advancement in contract negotiations between Watt and the Steelers has led many to speculate that the discussions may not be progressing smoothly. Adding fuel to this speculation, Watt recently shared a cryptic Instagram story that generated significant attention and discussion among fans and analysts. Because of this, rumors have begun to circulate suggesting the possibility of the Steelers potentially trading their star defensive player. Given Watt's pivotal role and immense impact on the Steelers' defense, this possibility has prompted widespread curiosity and debate regarding the potential compensation the team might receive in return for trading such a valuable asset. 

Among those publicly discussing this hypothetical scenario are Mike Florio and Chris Simms, who recently addressed the topic during a segment on their show, Pro Football Talk, offering their insights and potential trade scenarios.

"Certainly you're gonna have to give him a new deal, so that takes away a little from the value there, but you're going to get a 1 (first-round pick), a 2 (second-round pick), and maybe something else," Simms shared. 

As the 2025 NFL Draft rapidly approaches, taking place later this month in April, these ongoing discussions surrounding Watt's contract situation and potential trade scenarios take on increased significance. It is also crucial to consider the unique array of the Steelers' draft selections this year. As a consequence of acquiring Metcalf, the team traded away their second-round pick, creating a substantial void and a considerable gap between their first-round selection and their next pick in the third round. Furthermore, due to the Steelers' playoff appearance and resulting regular-season record from the previous year, their first-round draft pick is not among the highest in the draft order, currently positioned at the 21st overall selection. 

This specific draft capital landscape introduces a complex dynamic, suggesting that a player of Watt's caliber could potentially be leveraged to acquire more valuable draft assets, perhaps including an earlier pick or additional selections to help fill the void in the second-round. However, the fundamental question remains whether the potential gain in draft capital would truly outweigh the immense value and impact that Watt brings to the team's defense and overall competitiveness. The decision of whether to trade a player of his stature for future draft considerations presents a significant strategic dilemma for the Steelers organization as they navigate the crucial period leading up to the draft.

Entering the final year of his current contract with the Steelers, Watt is slated to earn approximately $21 million for the upcoming season. This compensation, while substantial, falls demonstrably short when compared to the lucrative contracts recently secured by other elite edge rushers in the NFL, including an AFC North divisional rival, Myles Garrett of the Cleveland Browns, who recently signed a significant four-year extension valued at $160 million. Given Watt's consistent and exceptional level of performance on the field, where he continues to be a dominant force and a game-changing presence for the Steelers' defense, it is highly probable that his next contract negotiation will aim to reflect his considerable value to the team and his standing among the top defensive players in the league, potentially positioning him among the highest-paid at his position.

Are Draft Picks For The Steelers Worth The Loss Of Watt?

Watt's journey in the NFL began in 2017 when the Steelers selected him in the first-round of the draft, making him the 30th overall pick. Throughout his entire career, Watt has been a member of the Steelers organization, establishing a strong and consistent presence on their defense. His impactful performances and unwavering commitment have resonated deeply with the team's passionate fanbase, solidifying his status as a beloved figure in Pittsburgh. Consequently, the potential departure of a player of Watt's caliber would represent a significant loss for the Steelers, both on and off the field. Many observers and analysts believe that the strength and foundation of the current Steelers roster lie predominantly within their defense, making the prospect of weakening that unit a concerning one for many. 

As with any decision involving the NFL Draft, there is an inherent element of risk and uncertainty associated with trading a proven star for future potential. Ultimately, all current discussions remain speculative, and no definitive outcome can be confirmed until an official announcement is made by the Steelers organization or Watt himself. As the 2025 NFL Draft draws ever closer, and the team faces the ongoing need to address various gaps and positional needs on their roster, it will be interesting to see whether Watt's recent cryptic activity on Instagram ultimately foreshadowed a significant development regarding his future with the franchise.

#SteelerNation