Former Steelers Safety Ryan Clark On The Uncertain Aaron Rodgers Situation: "It Makes Me Sick"

As the offseason progresses, the Pittsburgh Steelers have consistently been a central topic of widespread discussion and speculation across the NFL. A significant portion of this attention has focused intently on veteran quarterback Aaron Rodgers, who has emerged as the most prominent name being considered to fill the Steelers' pressing need for a starting quarterback. However, the potential acquisition of Rodgers has ignited a diverse range of opinions and sparked considerable debate among fans, analysts, and former players alike.

Although several factors contribute to the ongoing discussions surrounding Rodgers and the Steelers, a primary source of contention and frustration stems from the extended duration of Rodgers' decision-making process. Numerous reports have indicated that the Steelers have formally presented a contract offer to the veteran quarterback and are currently in a state of waiting for his response. For the Steelers' fanbase, this period of uncertainty has felt exceptionally long, and with each passing day without a resolution, the level of impatience and frustration among supporters continues to escalate. The protracted silence from Rodgers has fueled speculation and anxiety about the team's quarterback situation heading into the upcoming season.

This growing frustration extends beyond the fanbase and includes prominent analysts as well. On a recent episode of ESPN's Get Up, Ryan Clark, a former Super Bowl-winning safety for the Steelers, voiced his own frustrations with the prolonged Rodgers situation and shared his perspectives on the matter. When directly asked for his feelings regarding the ongoing uncertainty, Clark offered the following remarks.

"It makes me sick, to be honest," Clark responded. 

Drawing upon his experience as a former member of the Steelers organization, Clark expressed his strong disapproval of how the team appears to be managing the Rodgers situation. His concern extends to the Steelers' front office, which Clark believes has significantly mishandled the entire process. This criticism comes at a particularly critical time, with the 2025 NFL Draft rapidly approaching at the end of this month. The Draft presents the Steelers with a crucial opportunity to select their long-term franchise quarterback, a goal that the organization has reportedly prioritized for either this year's draft or the following one. Consequently, Rodgers' impending decision carries significant weight, as it will undoubtedly have a substantial impact on the Steelers' ultimate draft strategy and the direction they choose to take in addressing their quarterback needs.

Clark's concerns appear to encompass not only the Steelers' handling of the situation but also the actions and considerations of Rodgers himself. Rodgers, at 41, is the oldest active player in the NFL, a factor that understandably raises concerns for some, including Clark, who articulated his reservations regarding the veteran quarterback.

"What has Aaron Rodgers done in the last two years or since leaving [the] Green Bay [Packers], that says he should be afforded this type of time?" Clark asked. 

Rodgers notably suffered a significant Achilles tendon rupture during the opening drive of the 2023 season while playing for the New York Jets. This injury was particularly impactful not only because it sidelined him for the entirety of what was supposed to be his debut season with his new team, but also due to his advanced age for an NFL player. Recovery from such a severe injury can be challenging. Typically, the first year is focused on regaining basic form, while true improvement often comes in the second year, making 2025 a pivotal season for Rodgers. The long and demanding rehabilitation process associated with an Achilles tear, especially for an older athlete, adds a layer of uncertainty to his potential performance and longevity moving forward.

A Deadline From The Steelers Is Necessary

The ongoing delay in receiving a definitive decision from Rodgers is creating an increasing urgency for a resolution, particularly with the 2025 NFL Draft quickly approaching and Organized Team Activities (OTAs) scheduled to begin soon. The Steelers and their fan base are in a state of limbo, awaiting Rodgers' choice, and the continued lack of clarity is fueling growing frustration both within the team's supporters and across the wider league. 

The longer Rodgers takes to make his decision, the less time the Steelers will have to solidify their quarterback plans for the upcoming season, whether that involves integrating Rodgers or pivoting to alternative strategies, potentially including their approach to the upcoming draft. This protracted uncertainty is becoming increasingly problematic as crucial offseason preparation periods draw near.

Currently, the apparent fallback option for the Steelers at quarterback is Mason Rudolph, whom the team has re-signed during this offseason. While Rudolph may not be the preferred choice for a significant portion of the fanbase as the prospective starting quarterback, it is nonetheless important to acknowledge the team's established backup plan should Rodgers ultimately decide to pursue a different path. 

Furthermore, the Steelers are also exploring the possibility of drafting a quarterback in the upcoming 2025 NFL Draft, with reports indicating a mutual interest between the organization and highly regarded quarterback prospect Shedeur Sanders. Consequently, the Steelers' ultimate approach and the composition of their quarterback room for the upcoming season presents an intriguing and closely watched scenario. How the Rodgers situation, having Rudolph, and possibly drafting Sanders all come together will decide what the Steelers' quarterback situation looks like.

Who do you want to see at the Steelers' quarterback position? Let us know in the comments below!

#SteelerNation